Gift Card Scams: The Payment Method Is the Red Flag

Short answer: Gift card scams ask you to pay with gift cards because the money is hard to trace and almost impossible to get back once the card numbers are shared. No real company, government agency, or bank will ever ask you to pay a bill, a tax, or a fee with gift cards. If someone tells you to buy gift cards and read back the numbers, that is the scam, no matter who they claim to be.

How this scam works

It starts with a call, text, email, or message that creates fear or urgency. The scammer may pretend to be the IRS, your bank, a tech support team, or a company you use, and say you owe money, your account will be closed, or your computer has a virus. They tell you the only way to fix it is to buy gift cards.

Next, they tell you which cards to buy and how much to put on each one, often from a specific store. They stay on the phone while you go to the store, and they tell you to keep it secret or to say the cards are a gift. Once you have the cards, they ask you to scratch off the code on the back and read the numbers to them.

As soon as you share the numbers, the scammer can spend or sell the balance in minutes. The money is gone, and the store, the card company, and your bank usually cannot get it back. Gift cards are a favourite tool for scammers because they work like cash and leave little trace.

Gift cards are also used in other scams, such as fake job offers, romance scams, and fake online sales. In every case, the payment method is the warning sign. A real business will accept normal payment methods, and it will never ask for gift card numbers over the phone.

Red flags

  • Anyone asks you to pay with gift cards, especially for taxes, bills, fines, or tech support.
  • You are told to buy specific gift cards, keep it secret, or lie to the store about why you need them.
  • You are asked to scratch off the code and read the numbers, or send a photo of the cards.
  • The caller creates urgency, such as arrest, account closure, or losing a job or a prize.
  • The payment is for something you did not expect, from a person or company you did not contact first.

What to do if it happened to you

Contact the gift card company at once, using the number on the back of the card or on its official website, and ask if the card can be frozen. Give them the card numbers, the store where you bought them, and when you bought them. The sooner you call, the better the chance that some money is left.

Keep the cards, the receipts, and any messages from the scammer. If you paid by card or bank transfer to buy the gift cards, contact your bank and ask about disputing the purchase. Do not buy more cards or send more money to “fix” the problem.

Report the scam to the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov and read the FTC’s advice on gift card scams at consumer.ftc.gov. If the scammer pretended to be a specific company or agency, report it to that company or agency too.

Sources: Federal Trade Commission, “Gift Card Scams”; Federal Trade Commission, “How to Recognize and Avoid Phishing Scams”; ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

Will a real company ever ask me to pay with gift cards?

No. No real company, government agency, or bank will ask you to pay a bill, tax, or fee with gift cards. That request is always a scam.

Can I get money back from a gift card scam?

It is very hard, because the balance can be spent in minutes. Call the gift card company at once and ask if the card can be frozen, and report the scam to the FTC.

What should I do if a caller stays on the phone while I buy gift cards?

Hang up. A real company will never stay on the phone while you buy gift cards. Do not buy the cards, and do not share any card numbers.

How do I report a gift card scam?

Report it to the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov, to the gift card company, and to the company or agency the scammer pretended to be. Keep the cards and receipts.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments are reviewed before they appear. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use, and you are responsible for what you write.

Scroll to Top